popcorn bowl

Archived Reviews

 

STAR TREK: VOYAGER

5/16/2001

 


With the season finale coming next week, and after viewing this week's show, I have one request: NO MORE SINGING. The show opened with the Doctor singing opera and here in the 7th season, I've really just had it with the singing. In fact, the show opened terribly, I'm just glad it got more fun after we got through the opening theme & the first batch of commercials. The Doctor & the Captain were on their way to a medical conference -- can someone explain this to me? They've spent years trying to get home and now suddenly they're going to conferences & seminars. Excuse me? And why would the Doctor NEED to go to a conference, couldn't he better absorb information in some kind of data stream? I'm sorry, but these things bother me. I just keep thinking they could have come up with a better reason to get the Doctor & the Captain in the Delta Flyer.

Still, I loved the Captain's strange behavior upon her return. She took Chakotay into her ready room and explained that they were in space belonging to aliens who had 50 times their technological capacity, and could destroy them without blinking, AND they were ecological extremists...Greenpeace gone mad with lots of firepower. So Voyager was going to hand over their warp core, and everybody was going to go settle on a nearby planet.

What?

Fortunately, Chakotay had the same reaction I did, especially when Janeway started talking to herself on the bridge. big-head aliensTurns out Janeway was really the Doctor, downloading various crew members' data into his holomatrix so he could pose as each of them, all to save the Captain's life because she was being held captive by some rotund big-head aliens in silly outfits. Remember the dumbass aliens who held Geordi hostage because he knew how to fix things? They were sort of like those guys, but a bit smarter. They rigged the Doctor so they could see everything he saw, and forced him to impersonate everybody until they got ahold of the warp core. I liked him best as B'Elanna, trying to get away from Tom's icky husband behavior - but I still think they spent far too much energy trying to set up those cool shots and sacrificed common sense to make it work. The Doctor lured B'Elanna to the Captain's quarters and then snuck away so he could pretend to be her, which is fine, but why did he transform into her FIRST, while they were still in the same hallway? Wouldn't he have been safer to wait until she'd safely passed him? All for the sake of the cool shot of one B'Elanna watching the other turn the corner. . .they seem to have gotten lazy over there in the final hours in the Voyager writers' offices.

But I liked that the crew was smart and figured out something was wrong quickly. On Next Generation they're always pretty smart but sometimes on Voyager or DS9 they'd get stupid and not report strange behavior or question it even though they've encountered a million aliens that can take over people's bodies or brains and make them do what they want.

AndJaneway and the Doctor the Doctor. . .like the singing, enough! They indulge him far too much. As far as I'm concerned, the reason holograms don't qualify as life forms - say, the way Data does - is for the exact reason that they CAN be programmed. The Doctor can be programmed to not love Seven or to forget he can sing (please) or to just stop being so demanding and annoying. If I were the Captain I would have kicked his ass for not obeying orders and putting the whole ship in danger just to save her. Maybe I would have completely reprogrammed him, without any regrets. I wouldn't have invited him out for coffee, that's for sure. And by the way, who's running the mess hall now that Neelix is gone?

One side note: they brought back Ensign Vorik, another familiar face from seasons past. I love that! I wonder if dead Seska will turn up in the final show. I like seeing these folks that we've had around from the beginning, it'll make the impact of going home that much better. (It still would have been better with Neelix around.)

So that's it: on Wednesday it all ends. I can't believe it. Vive la Voyageur!

red and black line

5/9/2001

 

Well goodbye Neelix. It would have been much more exciting if last week's preview hadn't shown what was going to happen in the THE LAST FIVE MINUTES of tonight's show. Hello? They totally gave away the biggest thing to happen in the show a whole week ago. I think it kind of sucks for Neelix that he doesn't get to be in the final Voyager show. At least now he gets to live behind a shield on some asteroid with a bunch of scared Talaxians who ALL have Xes in their names. I'm not kidding. Dexa, Oxilon, Brax. . .and I remember an old episode where Neelix talked about his sister, and I just looked it up, and what was her name? Alixia. I can't, I just can't.

And while it was nice to see Naomi Wildman again, it would have been even nicer to see her Mom too, or at least to have had somebody mention her.

The story was pretty lame. The evil miners creepy miner-alienswere really creepy-looking aliens, but their skin reminded me of the kid that's born in "Demon Seed". They also backed off of that fight far too easily, Neelix managed to disarm three of them in about five seconds. No wonder he wanted to stay with the other Talaxians, he finally has a chance to be the tough guy. And all they needed to do to stop the aliens was put up a shield? This must not be a very dangerous area of the galaxy.

 

Neelix and his new girlfriend

   All in all, it was a sad send-off for Neelix. I don't know if I would have felt the same way if the preview hadn't RUINED it, but I hope they end the show on a bigger bang than this.

red and black line

5/2/2001

 


This was such a good show, and you'd never guess it from looking at those pictures. Right? Sure, it should really have aired a few seasons ago, it didn't relate to the whole getting-home thing at ALL -- in fact it seemed a bit weird to be going to conferences & going Chakotay and his new friendon shore leave in the middle of everything -- but it was a great story, it could even have been a little longer. Things got a little rushed at the end but I'm not complaining, it was action-packed.

Good Prime Directive story, too, especially since they actually followed it for a change. And fun along the way, with Seven of Nine & Chakotay stranded, Tom having to take pilot lessons with a boring instructor, funky native people who communicate by sign language, really big stakes (an entire civilization) and lots of beauty shots. COOL. And they tied the stories together nicely at the end, when Voyager got stuck so Janeway sent encoded orders to Tom, in the middle of his pilot instruction in the Delta Flyer, and he had to whip over to the planet, beam up all the bad people and reactivate the shield to stop them from going back.

   Seven and Chakotay in the jungle   Seven's holodeck fantasyThe only thing that was missing was a little romantic tension between Chakotay & Seven, since we know from earlier this season that she digs him. Seven, as always, is just the coolest, making her way through the jungle, learning to speak the sign languge, not being able to keep her hair up in that crazy bun. I liked Chakotay freaking out when the natives started decorating their faces to look like his tattoo, I was so sure Seven was going to come back and find out he'd been made God of The Silent People.

So they do get bonus points for a good episode, but it sure didn't feel like one of the last four, you know what I mean? The preview for next week indicates that Neelix is going away, but the previews on UPN are so badly done that I don't know if it's for real or some kind of fake-out. I won't read the previews or any gossip because I don't want to spoil the final episode. I can't think about the final episode or I'll get sad. What's going to happen to my Wednesday nights?

red and black line

4/25/2001

 
Lt. Carey and B'Elanna I can't believe it. I was JUST thinking about how the series is almost over forever, and wondering if they were going to bring back some people we haven't seen in a while, like Lt. Carey. He was there a lot in the first season, competing against B'Elanna for the Chief Engineer job, and then remember how nice he was when she got the gig instead of him? He had a very Miles O'Brien-like quality to him. I liked seeing him around.

So I turned on Voyager this week, and there he was! And it was as if he'd been there all along, they even gave him a first name and Tom said it as if they'd been hanging out for years. And then he mentioned having a wife, and a kid, so I knew right away that it was all over, it was like one of those army movies where a young soldier on his first mission pulls out a picture of his girlfriend. He may as well have been wearing one of those old red security shirts from the original series. (That, or they could have just painted a target on him.)


It was kind of a cool episode, though. The communication with Starfleet means that they can be sent on missions now, which could be fun, and I thought most of the show looked really great. The missiles were cool and the destroyed environment/nuclear winter looked amazing. The only really phony thing was the fake, limp, dangling rubber baby. It looked eerily like that alien in the guy's stomach in "Total Recall".

And I'm sorry, but I will never buy Tom & B'Elanna's relationship. Is it just me or do those two have zero chemistry? Chakotay has it with just about every woman on that show -- and I see he & Seven are getting stranded together next week, which should be especially interesting considering her recent holodeck fantasies about him -- but Tom & B'Elanna just don't do it for me. My fella & I just keep saying, "They're married" while we watch them to remind ourselves because there's NOTHING there between them. I will say this, though: Tom Paris is getting slightly less annoying over time. He had a lot of promise in those first few seasons but all that Captain Proton, I-love-the-20th-century-and-cars business was getting to me. I like when they bring back his training as a medic, that's more interesting to me than listening to him talk about hot rods.

I liked the alien they beamed up to the ship who had those goobily things all over his face, and he cleaned up nicely once they started treating him for radiation poisoning. I was just a little surprised at the end that the the Voyager crew didn't send more medicine to everybody else on the planet, I mean, it was Earth's fault that these people got their environment wrecked in the first place.


Lt. Carey action figureBut did they have to kill off Lt. Carey? Did they really have to? Couldn't he have made it home with the rest of them? I always like the peripheral characters on all the Star Treks. And they must have considered him as someone important at the beginning, since they even gave him his own action figure. He did get a great death scene, though, it was scary and dramatic and sad.

 

There are only THREE shows left before the series finale, I can't stand it.

R.I.P.
Lt. Joe Carey
April 25, 2001

 

blue line

4/18/2001

I really liked tonight's episode even though it the Doctor and Tuvokhad all the elements of a show that bores me silly: the Doctor as a central character, the holodeck as a primary location, no immediate physical danger for anybody, no real stakes for the ship or the universe, and no encounters with aliens, although they did have one blue guy. When they opened the show with the Doctor writing a holonovel, I had a nasty flashback to that unforgivably bad singing episode.

But I liked the novel he wrote, and it was really cool the way we got to see it along with each memberSpock with his mirror universe beard of the crew watching his or her own badass character in action. I liked Tuvok's beard, because it was a subtle little Spock-in-a-mirror-universe reference.I liked Tom Paris' trick to make the Doctor seehow obnoxious he was, and I usually find Tom Paris obnoxious. I even liked the names the Doctor gave everybody in his holo-novel. And I think it was a great way to dramatize the effect of looking at yourself through someone else's eyes in a flashy, fun way.

But I kept thinking of things to make the story better. How about all those communications that can suddenly come through on that new com signal? They could sow some seeds of apprehension Data's trialabout coming home. Maybe Janeway could find out that she's in some trouble with Starfleet for her renegade behavior in the Delta Quadrant. Maybe Chakotay, B'Elanna, and all the other Maquis should be starting to worry about getting put in jail when they get back. And all of that aside, Data went through a similar struggle for personhood way back when, and did it with a lot more humility. Remember? They had a trial to determine whether or not he was "a person". And the stakes were a lot higher for him, because if he lost, he was going to be disassembled. Ouch.

red and black line

4/11/2001
Q? Again? With a son? Oy vey.    Janeway and two Qs

We've already seen this story on Next Generation. Remember when the Continuum took away Q's powers and left him on the Enterprise? That was fun the first time around. It's not quite so enchanting the second.

I liked the bit where Q Junior sealed up Neelix's mouth & removed his vocal chords, it was very Twilight Zone, in a send-you-to-the-cornfield kind of way. But Q Senior's quick repair took all the creepy, scary fun out of it. I did, however, like his line to the Captain: "I even fixed your pet Talaxian."

And what was that deal at the end when Q handed Captain Janeway some PADD with information on how to shave a couple of years off the journey? Um, couldn't he just snap his fingers & send them to wherever he wanted? And his explanation for not sending them all the way home was very Gilligan's Island. He could have just said, "Because there are still six more episodes before the show's finale." It would have made more sense.


I was hoping the Voyager team would use the remaining shows to tell some interesting stories, but this wasn't one of them. And next week's preview reveals that BarclayBarclay is back for the 800th time. I wish Dwight Schultz would get a permanent acting gig and be too busy for Voyager. Isn't there an A-Team reunion coming up any time soon? (I know George Peppard is dead, but that can be worked into the plot.) Then we won't have holographic Barclays, hallucinating Barclays, stuttering Barclays, self-obsessed Barclays....just our regular Voyager characters that make us so happy. And if anyone's going to be recurring, they'd better be scary. There are already more than enough nice people on that ship.


Kind of makes you miss Seska, doesn't it? Those midnight reruns are getting to me.

 

back to Star Trek: Voyager OR back to Archives

home
home